Taiwan FSC Enacts Short-Selling Ban Amid Market Turmoil; Effectiveness Questioned
UpGateNeutralRegulation & policy

Taiwan FSC Enacts Short-Selling Ban Amid Market Turmoil; Effectiveness Questioned

Reading time: 4 min

Taiwan’s Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) has implemented a comprehensive ban on short selling below the previous day’s closing price, effective November 23rd, aiming to stabilize the stock market. This marks the first broad restriction of its kind in 11 years, following earlier measures designated ‘1.0’ and ‘2.0’ on November 9th and November 20th, respectively.

The new regulation, referred to as ‘short-selling ban 3.0’, prohibits short selling of all listed and over-the-counter stocks, along with Taiwan Depository Receipts, at prices lower than the preceding business day’s close. This iteration removes the daily price drop threshold previously in place under ‘2.0’. In conjunction with the ban, the FSC is raising margin requirements for short selling to 150%, halting new applications for put warrants, and encouraging share buybacks and the recall or cessation of share lending.

This regulatory move follows significant market declines. On Friday, November 20th, the Taiwan Weighted Index plummeted by 2,393.60 points to close at 36,033.29, a weekly decrease of 17.5%. The Taiex Futures (December contract) night session also experienced a sharp drop. These losses mirrored substantial declines in global markets, with the Nasdaq down 5.28%, the S&P 500 off 3.70%, and the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index falling 10.73% on the same day. Nvidia shares dropped 14.01%, and TSMC ADRs declined 9.48%.

According to the FSC, the ban does not impact general investors selling their existing holdings and has no set end date, with adjustments planned “in a timely manner.” However, the efficacy of these measures in the current market climate is uncertain. Reports indicate that Friday’s short selling volume was approximately 3.5 billion NTD, a figure considerably lower than the reduction in margin financing and hedging sales by proprietary traders, suggesting the ban’s direct impact on trading volume may be limited.

Investor sentiment appears strained, reflected in the decrease of the total market margin balance to 435.227 billion NTD on November 20th, a daily reduction of 49.141 billion NTD. The overall margin maintenance ratio fell from 156.18% to 151.78%. Notably, 6,462 accounts fell below the 130% margin maintenance ratio threshold, requiring additional payments totaling 6.464 billion NTD, underscoring financial pressure on some investors.

Looking ahead, market participants are closely monitoring upcoming US economic data. Key releases scheduled for November 25th include the October PCE price index, core PCE price index, personal income and spending data, the second estimate for Q3 US GDP, October durable goods orders, and initial jobless claims. These indicators are crucial for inflation and economic growth assessments, which will significantly influence the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy. The CME FedWatch tool shows over a 90% probability of a 0.25 percentage point interest rate hike at the December 8-9 meeting, a sentiment echoed by Fed Governor Cook’s remarks on the risks of delaying rate hikes.

The approaching Thanksgiving holiday week in the US introduces potential for increased market volatility. The concentration of significant economic data releases on Wednesday, November 25th, followed by reduced liquidity due to the holiday, could lead to greater price fluctuations. US stock markets are scheduled to be closed on November 26th.

Despite the FSC’s intervention, the market faces considerable uncertainty. The effectiveness of the short-selling ban against global economic pressures and upcoming US data remains to be seen. While historical data indicates that Taiwan’s stock market has found a bottom after short-selling bans in 4 out of 5 previous instances, this outcome is not guaranteed. The market is currently experiencing a high level of fear, as indicated by the VIX index exceeding 33. The interplay between domestic regulatory actions and international macroeconomic trends will likely shape market direction in the near term.

Why This Matters

The materials describe a narrow update: The FSC has implemented a new regulation, referred to as ‘short-selling ban 3. The duration and ultimate impact of the FSC’s short-selling ban.

Broader Context

Source materials place the factual news in this context: The article references previous short-selling measures: 1.0 (implemented November 9th) reduced intraday short selling volume limits and increased margin requirements. 2.0 (implemented November 20th) restricted short selling below the previous day’s closing price for stocks that dropped 3.5% or more and further reduced short selling limits.

Tags:UpGateNeutralRegulation & policy
Copied